As I am sure many respondents will say, the performance gains from an air filter are really not measurable. They are 95% psychological. However I would say this is more important than a couple of extra horses. The question you probably should be asking is which sounds better? There is a balance between sounding more “sporty”, but livable with and sounding very “sporty”, but the additional noise becomes wearing after a while depending on the type of use you get out of the car. If you just use it for a blast every now and then, you can afford to go for more induction noise, but as you have a later model, I suggest you probably use it more often for mixed motoring, so you do not want it to be overpowering.
All that said, I have not heard either, but I would bear it in mind… The same goes for exhausts, which give a similar output - some are too loud, but for some users, this is the effect they want.
I remember my first car - an MG metro - it was 1983!!! and I changed the air filter for a K&N and when on the motorway it was so loud that the stereo was overpowered - and as a teenager I had upgraded this too…