NB 2004 1.8 Manual Transmission 52.000 miles (82.000 km)
I have a very unusual or strange situation - all gearshifts are smooth except 4-> 5 up-shift and 6 -> 5 down-shift, when I have a very distinct clutch judder. The symptoms are distinctly clutch judder but it is not pervasive as it would be for a failing clutch, and ONLY when 5th gear is involved. Any ideas?