I gave it a chance. Dull as dishwater, I’m afraid. Mk2 Jag looks like it ended up in a scrapyard, and likely to remain there. Spectacularly nerdish Bond Bug expert; probably the fake part of the show (that a used car dealer can routinely get a club member to appraise a car, so he can slap £1000 on the sticker price). The main characters need to adopt raffish or eccentric clothes, or stupid head gear (oversized flatcap, or floppy beanie), rather than dirty polo shirts.
People might “like” the lack of fakery, but its going to be hard going when all they have to auction is a Fiesta 1100 Pop, in beige, or a crusty Maestro.
These programmes always run out of steam, because it turns out Joe Public aren’t that interesting, and most can’t string a sentence together on camera. So the presenters have to invent personas. The ones that last the course have strong characters; we tune in (an anachronistic phrase) because we are interested in what our favourite people are getting up to (hence internet meltdown when Edd China left). Of course there is a balance. Too much character can kill it. Bernie Fineman is the “star” in several shouty car shows; his persona is undoubtedly strong, but its a real turn off.
I’m not sure yet about "Flippin’ Bangers, which also has a similarly stupid title like Bangers and Mash. The characters are a slightly crazed looking boat builder, who is the mechanical one, and a car photographer, who is the dreaming amateur, Their weekly task; buy some modern classic, do it up, and sell it on. Its likely all faked, but so far interesting, as I can more easily relate to, say, an old Mk2 MX5 or a Porsche 924, than a Riley or Morris. Its likely to be consigned to scheduling oblivion like that old motorbike show on the Travel Channel.
Bangers and Mash is likely to suffer because it hasn’t got enough about Germans, secret weapons, impossible engineering or murderers.
For motoring type entertainment, these days I am mostly watching youtube channels, watching them big bald eagles, boggin’ deep, rippin’, having a heavy dose of freedom, doin’ it for Dale, while swiggin’ the Dew. Realism, but also escapism.
https://www.youtube.com/user/GARRETTmitch
Then you have curiously therapeutic channels, such as Yamaki Yard; a Japanese chap who silently tries to fix old broken stuff. Such as his Old Man’s late 80s Galant, which has been sitting up to its axles in a farmyard for 20+ years.
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCyh1Qc9BjZvDkslS_OM9-Rg/videos
There’s no commentary, no lift music, only occasional titles. After perfoming an absolute miracle in getting the car going (cylinders were full of water), he’s now attempting to weld up a severely rusted exhaust?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GIF1HlfSqgk