It’s one of those debated subjects that rears it’s head now and then.
To be frank, I have never flushed with any chemical additives in 40 years, and that is having owned everything from a Mini Clubman to an Opel Monza Turbo, a Vulcan milled 2.8i,…and a Yugo! (don’t ask)
What I don’t like about the idea is that I don’t think you can bet 100% that all the chemicals are drained out the (narrow) oilways before refill.
Furthermore, it carries the risk of dislodging hardened and minute particulates in the oil system that before were not doing a lot of harm.
Long gone are the days of de-coking, mineral oils etc where these sorts of products (like Redex) slid off the shelves.
The best “flush” in my opinion is regular oil changes with a “by the book” lubricant. Modern oils do superb job of cleaning as you go. I’ve used Castrol GTX for decades in everything (NOT Magnitec) and never had an issue with any cars, many of which sailed past 100,000 miles and beyond.
In a Mk1 especially I’d recommend a full filter/ oil change every 6 months or 4k miles whichever happens first. Some will say that’s overkill, perhaps so. I would counter it’s peace of mind and cheaper than a new engine.
Sometimes, though not always, 1st start HLA clacking can herald tired oil…but it should go quiet in under a minute, nor does it suggest some mechanical mishap on the horizon as the HLA buckets are simply pressuring/filling up…unless you have one of the later cars with solid lifters.
Note with these engines around a litre burned off per 1000 miles is “acceptable” anyway so it pays to check levels every 500 miles or so and there must be plenty old 1840cc cars zipping around burning off a bit more especially if they are revved “properly”
As for the “service” my jury is out on that one. It sounds a bit off colour and “woofly” From the video it seems to idle OK, but I’d go through everything EG have the plugs out. Simple things like new leads & plugs on these engines can work miracles. Have the timing checked. Maybe someone tried the 14 degree tweak and it’s not worked. In short, get the thing as far as possible back to basics first. Depending on the year of your car, you can take the CAT out. I think it’s '94 or prior…I think.
There’s a lot of what looks like post-radiator burst surface rust going on…so perhaps a double check of all electrical connections is advisable.
( It’s Lambda Sensor btw)![]()