What tyres are the best fit for me?

On the Yokos, the OE info was discussed here not so long ago. Essentially one speed rating is OE for Elise, the other for MX-5 ND.

In terms of replacement, I’ll probably also put another set of Yokos on when the time comes. I often use Kumho and like what they produce, although annoyingly the version mentioned above is XL rated which there’s really no need for on the MX-5.